in Fun & Random, Marketing & Media, Topics

What Is Influence?

What Is Influence?

September 21st, 2007 by Max Kalehoff

What is influence?

“That’s the million dollar question,” Duncan Watts, professor of sociology at Columbia University, and an outspoken critic of influencer and viral marketing, told me a few months back.

It was also the ultimate question this week at an Edelman roundtable, where I gathered with a small group of respected thinkers from diverse disciplines to tackle the issue in online environments.

With the rise of individual voices and the eroding effectiveness of mass marketing techniques, it’s no wonder that so many marketing and communications disciplines are enamored with cracking the code on influence. Specifically, influence among people.

So let’s address the core question: What is influence? According to Oxford, influence has a number of related definitions: 1. The power or ability to affect someone’s beliefs or actions. 2. A person or thing with such ability or power. 3 The power arising out of status, contacts, or wealth. 4 The power to produce a physical change.

For better or worse, I’ve seen marketing and communications professionals tackle all these definitions of influence from a variety of angles in recent months. Here are just a few, which range from elementary and practical, to academic:

Influence Identification: Can it be identified? Can it be measured? Can it be harnessed? Has nature determined any given person more influential than another? Or are there specific variables that ultimately determine influence, such as popularity, reach, expertise, trust, willingness to speak, history, or association?

Group Influence: What are the influence dynamics of groups? How do they differ from individuals? Are cohesive groups really more influential over their members? What brings them together and inspires them to act? How are people influenced by the cognitions and attitudes of others in their social group?

Emotional Impact On Influence: How do emotions affect the ability of one to influence or be influenced? Are happy people more likely to influence, while sad people are more likely to be influenced? How much is primal and in our subconscious?

Contextual Impact: How much does context or familiarity matter for influence to occur? As Jeff Jarvis noted at Edelman’s recent roundtable on online influence, it wasn’t necessarily his influence that sparked Dell Hell. It was the fact that his experience struck a chord with the pain of thousands of other customers across the Internet. Which then begs the question: Does influence behave differently online versus offline?

Influence of Algorithms: How do algorithms — particularly in Web services — influence people? Does Google influence by defining what people see and where to focus attention? Do search-based “meme trackers” like Techmeme or BuzzTracker have inordinate influence versus other information sources? What about social-voting sites like Digg or Do algorithms cultivate the influence of individual people?

Influence Application: Can influence really inform marketing communications strategy to achieve higher performance? Does it make better sense to segment and market to those who are most influential, or those who are most easily influenced? Or is it a mix of both? Can we influence the influencers, or are we limited to simply observing and reacting to their actions and ripples? Are these even the right question when applying influence to marketing strategy?

With all the attention around influence, and many unanswered questions, what we need most is more practical testing, tied to specific marketing objectives and applications. The marketer’s Holy Grail of influence is the ability to recognize patterns and optimize outcomes — whether for advertising, media-planning, public relations, word-of-mouth marketing, etc. Without question, influence often rides on nothing more than spontaneity. However, deeper understanding will lead to bets and actions with more favorable odds.

Is influence part of your marketing strategy?

(This column also ran in MediaPost.)

Write a Comment



  1. this is so much valuable for us like student. thank you soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo very much

  2. While we might end up “defining” influence, I suspect part of the larger issue will be how to make it work – and I don't think we'll ever really know. Individual influence varies across social, work and cultural groups. It also depends on other factors such as life stage.

    I think there's too many outlying factors and this is a rabbit hole.

  3. While we might end up “defining” influence, I suspect part of the larger issue will be how to make it work – and I don't think we'll ever really know. Individual influence varies across social, work and cultural groups. It also depends on other factors such as life stage.

    I think there's too many outlying factors and this is a rabbit hole.

  4. something that wasn’t mention here is the distinction between power and influence; Influence many times is mistaken for power. However research has shown that the best influencial figures, didn’t use power to assert influence, they used influence to gain power. For more on this visit

  5. If you must feed the fish, wait at least 2-3 days and feed them
    very small amounts. The bacteria e-coli are mostly accountable for this.

    Then find some woodworking plans and patterns for a nice little wooden bridge for
    over your pond and you are done.

  6. That would be reduce by the brand new program using a flexible line to 2 times.
    They will also find you the correct oil filter for the make and model.
    As this is actually the side the drain bolt is found on keep it on its side stand.


  • Social media white paper: defining influence « Technobabble 2.0 November 26, 2016

    […] the roundtable Max Kalehoff attempted to answer the question of defining influence. He […]

  • AttentionMax » Blog Archive » The Debate Continues: What Is Influence? November 26, 2016

    […] my recent post on different marketing dimensions in the discussion of influence.) Popularity: unranked […]

  • Hey! nielsen… opinion counts « Technobabble 2.0 November 26, 2016

    […] Opinion is what counts in today’s 2.0 world. Getting the news is the easy part – opinion is the current currency of the web. When it is valued it becomes a valuable commodity and helps to answer what Max Kalehoff queried in his recent post when he asked ‘what is influence’?  […]

  • Being Peter Kim: In the company of smart people November 26, 2016

    […] creator of the Social Media Index.  Max Kalehoff has written a post/column titled "What Is Influence?" that captures part of the discussion.  Henry Copeland pointed out a dissonance in blog […]