Absurdity: Reporters Should Be Disqualified Because They Care

May 7, 2007 · View Comments

loudobbs_60Minutes
Leslie Stahl on Lou Dobbs during the latest episode of CBS 60 Minutes:

Dobbs scoffs at suggestions that his advocacy tarnishes his credentials as a journalist.

Dobbs’ pre-recorded statement that prompted Stall’s declaration:

The idea that a reporter should be disqualified because he or she actually cares, actually isn’t neutral about the wellbeing of a country and its people…that’s absurd.

I don’t understand Lou Dobbs’ politics, but his statement is on the mark. For news people to believe they’re above the common man, to assume that a “fair-and-balanced” ideology is somehow immune from the flaws and impartiality of human nature and perspective, is a preposterous conviction.

Listen up, all you “journalists”: Credential and credibility come from trust, transparency and discourse, not some artificial oath to a robotic selection and interpretation of facts – otherwise known as objective, fair or balanced. Dobbs’ implicit concession that news is human is critical; that acknowledgment is the first step toward truth, if there even is “one.”

Related posts:

  1. We Should All Care Less About The Hi-Def DVD Format War
  2. Lookout Fox News! The British Are Coming!
  3. Our Inability To Think Rationally
  4. Taking Care Of Your Sick Kids
  5. Stolen Documents Fair Game In Reporting The News?
blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: